• Print Friendly and PDF
  • Print Friendly and PDF
Bill Brohaugh

Bill Brohaugh

COLLOQUY
As managing editor, Bill Brohaugh is responsible for the day-to-day management and editorial for the COLLOQUY magazine and colloquy.com, the most comprehensive loyalty marketing web site in the world. In addition to writing many of the feature articles, Bill develops the editorial calendar, hires and manages outside writers and researchers and oversees print and online production. He also contributes to COLLOQUY’s weekly email Market Alert and the COLLOQUYTalk series of white papers.
  • 0 comments 985 reads
    Posted on 2012-04-12

    It seems that some marketers are treating conversations with consumers via social media like the stereotyped tourists in a foreign country. If the locals don't understand the tourists' language, the tourists amp up the volume, as if repeating "I don't understand why you don't understand me!" with additional decibels! will simplify the translation. These marketers who aren't fully understanding the new language of social media can tend to get overly loud - or overly chummy.

    That's the finding of a recent study by Relevation Research, which surveyed 1,500 U.S. online consumers age 16 and older. The results show that 52% of respondents have Facebook-liked, Twitter-followed or otherwise "subscribed to" a company or brand. But of the group that expressed their "devotion," 32% had subsequently spurned the relationship. "After distancing themselves from the brand on social media, many report they then view the brand more negatively, shop/visit it less often and wind up...

  • 0 comments 1,061 reads
    Posted on 2012-04-03

    In "Supermarket checkout still stuck in the past," The Los Angeles Times has an interesting story about technology and the grocery industry. The Times notes that grocers have experimented with various technologies, but have been slow to adopt them because of cost and other factors. Quoting food-industry analyst Phil Lempert, editor of The Lempert Report, "Most consumers would rather have a competent cashier and bagger than any new technology." It's in part a matter of trusting technology, which leads to Lempert's view of the future: "But what people do trust and value is their smartphone, and that's an easy next step for the industry."

    A critical step in whatever technology is used - kiosks, websites, mobile apps, self-checkout, scanners or even (as we'll see in a moment) talking shopping carts - is that it center around the customer. The customer must not only receive benefit but also recognize benefit. Contributing editor Lance Du Chateau took up that...

  • 0 comments 757 reads
    Posted on 2012-03-26

    Me, I'm keeping my power washer to myself. I just have too much fun with it, hosing down the patio and the driveway and mumbling in Tim-Allenesque grunts, "More power!" Other consumers aren't so attached to such tools, and happily share them with neighbors and friends - especially if the group goes in together to pay for them. That's a practice that's been called "collaborative consumption" or "the sharing economy."

    And there's a social media component as well (what COLLOQUY calls "the I-Network"), which I wrote about earlier this week, in relation to a Citi ThankYou Rewards Point-Sharing app, and to study conducted by ad agency Campbell Mithun in partnership with Carbonview Research. The report notes "not only did 60% of overall respondents find the concept of sharing appealing, but a full 71% of those who have used shareable products expect to continue." More on that in the previous blog.

    But the study also noted some unusual things that survey respondents...

  • 0 comments 786 reads
    Posted on 2012-03-21

    In "Magna Cum Loyalty," COLLOQUY Managing Partner Kelly Hlavinka lauds Citi's new ThankYou Point-Sharing App, which enables ThankYou Rewards members to strive for group rewards by allowing them to pool rewards points with Facebook friends. We see this sharing-network concept as further evidence of the growing power of what we call "the I-Network." In the age of social media, consumers are creating their own networks that loyalty marketers must understand and address if their brands are to be allowed within those networks.

    A recent survey by ad agency Campbell Mithun in partnership with Carbonview Research quantifies an aspect of this trend (with such terminology as "the sharing economy" and "collaborative consumption" to describe when a group of people - neighbors, family, friends, and so on - purchase and share a product or service.)

    According to the study, "not only did 60% of overall respondents find the concept of sharing appealing, but a full 71% of...

  • 0 comments 879 reads
    Posted on 2012-03-19

    As I'll explain in a moment, I have only one set of toes.

    I highly suspect that that's true of most of your customers, as well. What leads to this important personal revelation is a study just released by the Pew Internet & American Life Project, relevant to those of us interested in, yes, customer relevance.

    Though the study is specific to search results and to targeted internet ads (those based on user searches and online activity), it opens a subject related to consumer relevance in marketing in general. Yes, the survey covers the usual privacy concerns: "73% of search users are not comfortable with search engines collecting user information to personalize search results because they see it as an invasion of their privacy." And 68% oppose targeted online advertising for the same reason. But, as discussed by my colleague Phaedra Hise in "The Relevance Resolution...Finally?," the cover story of our current issue, the traditional "say-do gap" that afflicts survey...

  • 0 comments 809 reads
    Posted on 2012-03-08

    I once participated in a grocer's loyalty program in kind of a tag-team fashion. Though the program was in my wife's name, we both participated in the program: my wife had the keyfob and I had the card, meaning our purchases reflected interests for the household in aggregate. And we were both loyal to that grocer, and appreciated the benefits of the program. Such sharing can be something of a headache for marketers who want to concentrate on learning about individuals (we both cooked, but vastly different cuisines), but in many ways, the whole of a household is an individual, with its purchase and behavior activity consolidated into one view.

    Besides, there are advantages to treating entire households as individuals, in a sense. When redemption offers have full-household benefit, the program becomes more attractive to the individual member, and becomes memorable to others in the household and, by extension, in the member's social network. That's good not only for currying...

  • 0 comments 1,010 reads
    Posted on 2012-02-29

    I'm a foodie, and I've said numerous times that my choice for a second profession would be professional grocery shopping. (I'm sensing an Xtreme shopping reality TV show coming on . . .).

    That's I'm both fascinated by and skeptical of an innovation I spotted courtesy of Geekwire. Whole Foods and Microsoft are working on a "smart shopping cart," one that uses tech from Microsoft's Kinect hardware to assist a grocery shopper's experience. Reports GeekWire: "The motorized cart identifies a shopper with a loyalty card, follows the shopper around the store [literally follows, the foodie points out], scans items as they're placed inside, marks them off the shopping list, and even checks the shopper out in the end."

    The fascinated foodie (and loyalty marketer) in me says, "Wow - there's a customer experience that results from the store really knowing me." The skeptical foodie (and loyalty marketer) in me says, "Um, hold on just a second."

    I'm going to quickly...

  • 0 comments 842 reads
    Posted on 2012-02-21

    "When it pains, it pours" is a phrase I've often heard, mainly because I made it up and I practiced it in front of the mirror several times before sitting down to write this blog (and of course I'm just kidding).

    Kidding or not, I don't need to tell you about the expressions of consumer pain pouring out when people social-mediate about negative experiences (real or imagined) about redeeming loyalty-program rewards - and specific to this discussion, frequent-flyer program redemptions. Blackouts, expiration, inability to upgrade from first class to sitting in the flight deck (just kidding again). Yes, consumers also social-mediate about great experiences, but I needn't go into all the theory and reality of how rumors and bad news and myths travel faster than, oh, the speed of your typical trans-continental flight, now do I?

    So it's refreshing to see an independent voice point out the fallacies surrounding myths about the programs we're involved in: "5 Myths Debunked for...

  • 0 comments 994 reads
    Posted on 2012-02-20

    This past holiday season, I found myself a few miles short of redeeming for a flight home to my native Wisconsin. Eager to see me mum and almost equally eager to not have to drive 10 hours to do it, I bought extra miles to top off the ticket. Yes, I'd have preferred to avoid the extra cost, but on the other hand, I appreciated the convenience and flexibility that purchasing extra miles gave me.

    Had I but known that instead of money, I might have been able to pay for my extra miles with unused coffee, steak dinners or CDs I've never listened to.

    Well, not literally, of course. But, United Continental has recently given MileagePlus members a choice to pay for extra miles with those very assets, in the form of unused balances on gift cards. Not unused coffee or dinners or CDs per se (we're not talking barter here), but the gift currency I might have used had I chosen to buy those items. MileagePlus members can register their gift cards from participating...

  • 0 comments 890 reads
    Posted on 2012-02-13

    And that headline would be "More Survey Results You Just Can't Make Up." Though obviously someone keeps making up the questions.

    COLLOQUY's Loyalty Landscape feature recently noted in an article titled, yes, "More Survey Results You Just Can't Make Up" that "Most travelers (75%) have lied to get a better room or a free amenity," according to an Affinia Hotels survey. At the time, we wondered just what those lies would be.

    Well, another survey, from the Starwood Preferred Guest frequent-guest program, gives us some potential insight: "Respondents were not above telling little white lies to get a better hotel room or hotel/airline travel upgrade. Nearly half of respondents, 45%, claimed they would pretend it was their honeymoon; 25% would pretend they had a family emergency; and 20% would pretend to be someone important."

    That leaves 10%.... perhaps those travelers who would fib in order to be mentioned in a smart-aleck COLLOQUY blog post.

    Editor's note...