Login or Join

The Customer-Centricity Paradox

dick_lee

The Customer-Centricity Paradox

comment count 5 comments | 2335 reads
Posted by Dick Lee on Jun 25, 2007

What’s the first thing that crosses a CXO mind, when he or she hears “customer-centricity” bandied about? For many execs, it’s “increased cost.” You betcha. “Gotta have so many mignions attending to so many needy customers that we’ll never post a profit increase.” And if you think about it, makes sense to frame customer-centricity this way.

But it’s wrong. Dead wrong. Wrong because, paradoxically, giving customers more of what they want requires fewer employees, rather than more employees. And managing head count is almost always the pillar of cost control.

Hopefully, now you’re really scratching your head. “How do we get to taking better care of customers by reducing head count?” Actually, by applying a fundamental business principle championed by folks including Jack Welch, Peter Drucker and damn near every organizational consultant on the planet.

Some, including Welch, call this principle “delayering.” At High-Yield Methods, we call it “rationalizing work” (to make sure everything adds value to customers). But whatever the name, it requires reducing “supervisory” layers to a bare minimum. And perhaps the most essential element of delayering is trusting and empowering line employees to make decisions without supervisory oversight (read “interference”).

Now here’s where good organizational strategy meets customer-centricity. Aside from quality products (which includes more than a dollop of service quality), what does research show to be customers’ highest priority? Dealing with empowered employees. Voila.

In a nutshell, delayering the organizational structure, which results in substantial cost reductions, doesn’t just work for companies. It works for customers as well. We rediscover this principle from the opposite direction virtually every time we reengineer business process. When we rationalize process to eliminate activity that doesn’t add value to customers, we very quickly come down to delayering. So in this case, doesn’t matter whether you start from a customer-centrric point of view or the customer perspective. You reach the same end point. Which doesn’t happen very often. Which is also why it’s so unexpected. Which makes it a paradox.

So next time you hear “customer-centricity” and “cost-control” used in the same breath, don’t belch.



0
No votes yet
 
Dick Lee
Consultant, author and educator Dick Lee, founded High-Yield Methods. In addition to his overall CRM expertise, Dick developed the first, "outside-in," customer-centric process approach, Visual Workflow. While helping clients implement CRM, including designing customer-centric process, HYM aligns process with business strategies and technology with process. For more information visit www.h-ym.com.
About Dick Lee   |   Follow on:
  • RSS
5 comments »

John I. Todor, Ph.D.

The Profitability of Customer-centricity

I hope some CXO are reading this blog.

Companies that really deploy customer-centric practices benefit financially in several additional ways. One, customers become more engaged and less price focused. Two, engagement increases commitment to the relationship and more tolerance for snafus. Three, engaged and committed customers are more potent advocated who recruit other high-value customers. And, advocates often serve as a free help-desk to those they recruit.

John I. Todor, Ph.D. is the author of Addicted Customers: How to Get Them Hooked on Your Company. (www.AddictedCustomers.com)

Phil Osborne

Customer centricity as out-sourcing

Viewed in this way customer centricity doesn't increase value FOR the customer, rather it increases value OF the customer to the firm which keeps the thinking 'firm centric'...

customer centricity is a leap of faith and while the search for proof continues, organisations that get it (and implement it) before the proof is found will prosper...

forget the attempts of conversion to the new faith, just as going to church on a Sunday doesn't make you religious (except in your habits), faking customer centricity to drive down costs doesn't cut it...

whether it drives down costs is not the point, what it does do is increase the value of your proposition / offering, which customers are prepared to 'pay' more for...

although pay in this sense may not equate to increased prices at each transaction, it likely means more transactions from each customer (increased CLV) and / or increased loyalty as more than transaction price is required to shift them to competitors

as an aside, adding value is a misnomer. it is production centric thinking. firms can't add value, because they don't produce value. they produce value propositions or potential value, without customers no value is created just costs; a warehouse full of products is not a warehouse full of value

dick_lee

dick_lee

Your blog comment

Dick Lee - we're in violent agreement about all your points. But keep in mind that the perceived addititional costs of becoming customer-centric act as a giant brake that keeps many companies from "taking the leap." The point I'm making is that we can and should spread the word that customer-centricity reduces operating costs, rather than adding to them, as an extra carrot to spur on more customer-centricity.

graham_hill

graham_hill

Show Me The Money

John, Phil

Missing so-far in this discussion has been any semblance of offering evidence, let alone proof, for the customer-centric proposition. It is not adequate to just say that "customer centricity is a leap of faith". If it is, then companies are well advised not to bother to make the leap and to stick to the not so customer-centric facts. Indeed, until evidence is gathered that show clearly that customer-centricity is a superior business strategy and how to make it work, a CXO implementing it would be being negligent in his duty to non-customer stakeholders.

We MUST rise above this motherhood and apple-pie approach to customer-centricity. Until we can provide hard evidence of the efficacy of customer-centricity, we should stop peddling it as the panacea for all ills.

Graham Hill

bob_thompson

bob_thompson

Customer-Centricity Not a Leap of Faith

Graham, there's plenty of evidence that a customer-centric approach can deliver business benefits, as you're well aware.

It's not the only way to make a buck, of course. Product innovation and cost leadership are still valid strategies, and can be used in combination with customer-centricity. If fact, I could argue that providing the best product or lowest cost is a form of customer-centricity, for customers that value such things.

A "customer-centric business strategy," in my view, is one where the enterprise delivers what the customer wants and in return receives revenue and profit. A win-win. I think part of the problem is that some may define being customer-centric as just being nice to the customer, no matter how much it hurts.

I don't believe customer-centric business should be a leap of faith. Perhaps we can use this thread to refine what customer-centricity really is, and when and how it can work for a business. And when it doesn't.

Bob Thompson, CustomerThink Corp.
Blog: Unconventional Wisdom

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
 
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <br> <img> <em> <i> <b> <u> <hr><strong> <table> <tr> <td> <th><ul> <ol> <li> </li><font><blockquote><sup> <colspan> <rowspan>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text, URLs will automatically be converted to links.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
Are you human? (This question helps prevent automated spam submissions.)

MarketPlace

Powering the New Customer-Conversation Driven Enterprise

[March 18, 10 AM PDT] With the exponential growth of the social web, enterprises need a new way to effectively collect and utilize unstructured information that can be used to drive business decisions. This webinar will discuss LARA, a new methodology to help enterprises more effectively Listen to, Analyze, Relate and Act on customer information.

Global Customer Experience Management Certification Program

[March 17-18, Paris] Learn cutting-edge CEM methods from a team of international gurus. This 2-day course applies CEM essentials, strategies and methodologies on Marketing, Sales and Services; provides a framework with relevant guiding principles and tools for designing the best experience to your customers.

Featured Links

Salesforce CRM

The leader in customer relationship management and cloud computing.

CEM Training and Certification

Patent-pending methodologies combine the art and science of Customer Experience Management.

On-Demand CRM Software

Use RightNow solutions to create the best possible customer experience while reducing costs.

Get your event or resource listed in the MarketPlace, reaching 300,000 business leaders monthly.
For more information, contact CustomerThink advertising sales.