Login or Join

The Skinny on the Trusting of Strangers in Social Media

john_todor

The Skinny on the Trusting of Strangers in Social Media

comment count 2 comments | 1432 reads
Posted by John Todor on Sep 23, 2008

It seems a little strange. In the physical world we seem increasingly suspicious of strangers. Yet, there is growing evidence that in the online social media world, we are increasingly find strangers trustworthy and are influenced by their opinions.

Here are the highlights from a Universal McCann study of 17,000 Internet Users from 29 countries. To be included in the study one had to be an active internet user—meaning they used the Internet at least every other day. That would include over 90% of my friends.

  • There has been a massive increase in the use of social media since 2006. It varies by the vehicle (blogs, social networking etc.) with doubling of participation very common and 4x increases being observed.

  • There has been a steady shift from passive participation to active creators of content. Writing blogs has risen from 28% to 44%; creating a social network page has grown from 27% to 57% and uploading a video clip from 10% to 42%. People are not just getting influenced by others, they are becoming influencers.
  • Personal experience and the personal experience of someone you trust are the main motivators for sharing opinions about products and brands. In spite of some folk lore, good experiences are more important motivators than bad experiences in getting someone to share opinions online.
  • Peer reviews are just as influential as professional content and product comparison sites.
  • The top four trusted forms of recommendations are all direct conversations: personal recommendations from friends/family; personal recommendation from a professional; emails from a trusted colleague; instant messenger from a friend or colleague. Not everything online is trusted: emails from companies are only marginally more trusted than celebrity recommendations that ranks at the bottom.
  • Age is assumed to be a big factor but this was simply not evident in the results. Trust of online sources did not significantly vary by age or gender. However, the more educated a person is, the more likely they are to trust the opinions of strangers.
  • A big surprise was the high levels of social commentary on what one would might have been low interest topics like utilities, financial services and groceries. The implication of this is that all products are now exposed to customer pre-purchase scrutiny.

In sum, this study adds to the growing evidence that companies must be concerned about their social media visibility. Furthermore, they must find open and credible ways to become part of the conversation.



5
Average: 5 (1 vote)
 
John Todor
John I. Todor, Ph.D., is the managing partner of The Whetstone Edge, LLC, a customer-centric consulting firm that helps clients build customer equity by engaging customers online via social media and delivering compelling offline customer experiences. He is the author of Get with it! The Hands-on Guide to Using Web 2.0 in Your Business.
About John Todor   |   Follow on:
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
2 comments »
andrew_rudin

andrew_rudin

Social Media Accelerates Opinion-Sharing and Expands Audiences

Thanks for sharing this insight. Well before printing presses created mass-produced information, people shared product opinions and information--many times without distinguishing between the two. For the most part, this information was shared face-to-face, where tangible trust builders or trust breakers could be experienced: what a person looked like, the clothes he or she wore, how he spoke, whether or not there was eye contact during the discussion. Of course, little of that is possible in an online world. So what exactly makes an online stranger trustworthy if we can't use the senses that humans have been wired to use over millions of years of evolution? In an online world, how, exactly, does trust convey between people?

These are challenging questions that should be answered as companies invest in social media strategies, an important recommendation you make in your blog.

In my own experience, when I read the opinions of people I don't know online, there are some I'm more inclined to trust than others. What makes them so, I can't totally put my finger on.

Perhaps this is a subject for a valuable study: What facilitates trust in Social Media? If you know of any articles that definitively address this topic, I would be interested in knowing about them.

john_todor

john_todor

More Opinion the Better

Andy,

I think you are on to an important dimension of customer generated content and influence. At this point, more reviews seem to be better, even if they include some weak or negative reviews. Here is my take on this. When reading reviews, people are trying to determine if this person is someone like themselves. They want to know if they value the same things, especially when it comes to the experience. For example, someone might review a hotel and say the hot tub was not hot enough. That might not resonant with me. Another might say the hotel is within walking distance of great restaurants and coffee house. This would resonant with me. The latter would carry weigh even if the star rating was not a five.

On negative comments, if they are all negative then they may have an impact. If a few are negative, they can add credibility as we know not everyone like and values the same things.

A good source for online peer influence is www.bazaarvoice.com. They are a vendor in the space but do provide a list of research and statistics on what is happening in this area.

John
John I. Todor, Ph.D.
Author of Get With it! The Hands-on Guide to Using Web 2.0 in Your Business.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
 
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <br> <img> <em> <i> <b> <u> <hr><strong> <table> <tr> <td> <th><ul> <ol> <li> </li><font><blockquote><sup> <colspan> <rowspan>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text, URLs will automatically be converted to links.

More information about formatting options

You can change the default for this field in "Comment follow-up notification settings" on your account edit page.
CAPTCHA
Are you human? (This question helps prevent automated spam submissions.)

MarketPlace

Global Customer Experience Management Certification Program

[August 19-20, Johannesburg] Learn cutting-edge CEM methods from a team of international gurus. This 2-day course applies CEM essentials, strategies and methodologies on Marketing, Sales and Services; provides a framework with relevant guiding principles and tools for designing the best experience to your customers.

Customer Experience Management (CEM) Certification Program

[Oct 5-7, Scottsdale; Nov 15-16, London] Innovate, Differentiate, Execute–Learn how from the leaders who did it. Packed with 200 templates, tools and fast affordable ideas, this 2-day workshop is your path to execution. Money Back Guarantee.

Lessons in Loyalty: How Southwest Airlines Does It - An Insider's Point of View

Southwest Airlines recognized long ago that they were in the customer service industry, they just happened to fly airplanes. They built and maintained one of the most faithful customer bases in existence today. Read this white paper to discover how to boost the level of customer loyalty in your organization.

Empower Mobile Salesforce.com Users to Close More Deals

The economy may be recovering, but is your sales force prepared to capitalize on increased demand? Learn how to empower on-the-go sales reps with innovative mobile sales tools and electronic signature solutions to increase sales productivity.

Social Media Customer Service: Show Me the Money (or the Gold)

Hundreds of millions of engaged consumers have flocked to social media sites, with companies rushing to mine this new opportunity. Learn how the winners have approached this early "gold rush" by incorporating social media in cross-channel conversations, using social media analytics and engaging customers.

Social Business Executive Summit: How to Win in the Social Economy

This virtual Summit featured thought leaders in Social CRM, Enterprise 2.0 and Social Media Marketing. View recordings and download slides from six sessions on social business strategy, customer communities, employee collaboration... and how social computing will transform marketing, sales and customer service. Recorded May 25-27, 2010. Sponsored by InsideView, Genesys, Jive, Marketo and RightNow.

Using Social Media To Enhance Your Customer Feedback Program

Traditional Voice of Customer programs rely on survey techniques. Now the Social Web provides an additional source of customer feedback data. Learn how to use social media to listen, analyze, and act on vital feedback from your customers.

Featured Links

Salesforce CRM

The leader in customer relationship management and cloud computing.

CEM Training and Certification

Patent-pending methodologies combine the art and science of Customer Experience Management.

On-Demand CRM Software

Use RightNow solutions to create the best possible customer experience while reducing costs.

Get your event or resource listed in the MarketPlace, reaching 300,000 business leaders monthly.
For more information, contact CustomerThink advertising sales.