On Lipstick and Pigs: Sales Promotions and Customer Loyalty
0 comments | 4133 reads Steve Yastrow, over on the Tom Peters site, asks if a bribe can lead to loyalty and whether 'loyalty programs' can deliver loyalty.
Well, Duh, as you Yanks like to say (I prefer 'D'ohhh' a la Homer Simpson, but not quite the same meaning, is it). Anyone who's been paying attention for the past few years - and apparently that's not a lot of people - could have told you these basic marketing rules:
1. Sales promotions are designed to create a short-term sales spike or smooth out seasonal dips in sales. They are a tactical tool.
2. In response to the perceived need for 'customer loyalty', sales promotions suddenly got dressed up in new clothes. Give the program a card for customers to put in their wallet, stretch the timescale out so it lasts, say, all year round. Call it a loyalty program and what have you got? Well, to borrow from a political debate in the US at the moment, you've got a pig with lipstick on.
I wrote an article for Marketing Week a couple of years ago pointing out that most of the loyalty promotion, card-based programs and schemes are just sales promotional tools in disguise and can't/won't ever deliver customer loyalty.
Steve Yastrow puts his finger on it when he says that most so-called loyalty schemes encourage repeat purchases, and that's not the same as loyalty. It's still just a transactional relationship. And a transactional relationship isn't really a relationship at all.
On the other hand, just to be Devil's advocate, here...If you can keep millions of customers coming back for repeat purchases through ongoing discounts that lead them from one transactional encounter to another (as Tesco does with its Clubcard, probably the nearest thing to a genuine 'loyalty' program there is among the card-based schemes), who cares if it's real loyalty or not? The end-result is the same.
Suddenly that pig's not looking so unattractive after all.
Phil Dourado
- About Phil Dourado |
Connect:
- 4133 reads
0 comments »
Join the conversation!
MarketPlace
Boost Customer Satisfaction & Loyalty at SCORE 2013
[May 29-31, Boston] Customer experience management (CEM) strategy meets customer operations at SCORE Conference 2013. Topics include driving customer satisfaction and loyalty, employee engagement, customer retention, call center technology and big data analytics. CustomerThink members save $700 off the regular registration fee.
Digital vs. Human Banking Experiences: Can This Be a Happy Marriage?
[June 6] It's time for banking leaders to rethink how to nurture and grow customer relationships in an increasingly digital world. Get the results of a new study that revealed the CX practices of top performing banks. Learn how digital Innovations can enable more personal service.
[June 10-13, Chicago] If you are responsible for the results of your company’s website, social media, ecommerce, web intelligence, data strategy, audience research and/or measurement, then mark your calendar. Customerthink members save 15% off full conference passes with code CTKTO15.
[June 10-13, Chicago] PAW's program will feature over 40 sessions with case studies so you can witness how predictive analytics is applied at leading enterprises. Customerthink members save 15% off full conference passes with code CTKTO15.
Confirmit’s Community Conference ’13 – London and Las Vegas
[June 19-21, London; June 26-28, Las Vegas] Attending CCC ‘13 gives you an unrivaled opportunity to understand and address rapid industry changes and discover new techniques that can drive your business forward. Create a tailored agenda that explains how to overcome the challenges your business faces. Take advantage of excellent networking opportunities and face-to-face discussions with thought leaders.
Global Customer Experience Management (CEM) Certification Program
[Sept 19-20, Amsterdam; Sept 24-25, Sao Paulo; Nov 12-13, San Francisco] An internationally recognized program with proven track record of success - being run for 40 times in 17 cities with attendees from 58 countries, the program is developed based on the U.S. patent-pending Branded CEM Method which aims to drive customer loyalty and brand differentiation with quantifiable business results. Limited offer: USD300 early bird discount.
Customer Experience Certification
[Sept 24-26, London] If you’re developing a customer experience program or want to review your current approach, join other customer experience leaders for this intensive 2.5-day certification. Presented by Medallia, the global leader in customer experience management. Enter code ‘Cthink’ to save$300/£200.
Voice of Customer 2.0: Creating Change Your Customers and Employees Can Believe In
[Recorded April 25] Despite good intentions, in the majority of companies Voice of Customer programs contribute little to business success. Join us to learn the secrets to capitalize on Customer Experience feedback, so you can drive organization actions that will unlock profitable growth.
Get your event or resource listed in the MarketPlace, reaching 200,000 business leaders monthly.
For more information, contact
CustomerThink advertising sales.
Follow CustomerThink
The Future of Work - Please Give Your Input
CustomerThink is collaborating with Chess Media Group in a study about "The Future of Work" including the use of social/collaborative tools. Please take a few minutes to share your input. As thanks for your time, you'll receive a complimentary copy of the report.
Featured Resources
